|
Conservatives, liberals and blacks
Walter E. Williams
August 4, 2004
During the first Reagan administration, I
participated in a number of press conferences on either
a book or article I'd written or as a panelist in a
discussion of White House public policy. On occasion,
when the question-and-answer session began, I'd tell the
press, "You can treat me like a white person. Ask hard,
penetrating questions." The remark often brought
uncomfortable laughter, but I was dead serious. If there
is one general characteristic of white liberals, it's
their condescending and demeaning attitude toward
blacks.
According to a Washington Times story (July 14,
2004), Democratic hopeful Sen. John Kerry, in a speech
about education to a predominantly black audience, said
that there are more blacks in prison than in college.
"That's unacceptable, but it's not their fault," he
said. Do you think Kerry would also say that white
inmates are faultless? Aside from Kerry being factually
wrong about the black prison population vs. the black
college population, his vision differs little from one
that holds that blacks are a rudderless, victimized
people who cannot control their destiny and whose best
hope depends upon the benevolence of white people.
Have you watched some white politicians talking to
black audiences? It's bad enough to watch the Revs. Al
Sharpton and Jesse Jackson do an imitation of Flip
Wilson's Rev. Leroy. But to watch Al Gore and Bill
Clinton do it is insulting at the least. They don't talk
to white audiences that way. As a matter of fact,
Sharpton and Jackson don't talk to white audiences that
way, either -- talking about going from the outhouse to
the White House and from disgrace to amazing grace and
other such nonsense. By the way, after addressing the
NAACP's 95th annual convention in Philadelphia, Kerry
gave the audience the black power clenched-fist salute.
I wonder whether his white audiences get the black power
salute as well.
On July 23, President Bush gave a speech to the
National Urban League. Unlike so many other white
politicians speaking before predominantly black
audiences, Bush didn't bother to pander and supplicate.
He spoke of educational accountability and school choice
and condemned high taxes, increased regulation and
predatory lawsuits. He defended the institution of
marriage. He didn't see blacks as victims in need of a
paternalistic government to come to our rescue. He saw
blacks needing what every American needs -- an
environment where there's rule of law, limited
government and equality before the law. The most
important question President Bush left with the audience
was whether blacks should give the Democratic Party a
monopoly over their vote and take their votes for
granted.
Sen. Kerry and others have criticized Bush for
snubbing the NAACP convention. Here's my question to
you. If you were president, would you speak before a
group whose president, Kweisi Mfume, said, "We have a
president that's prepared to take us back to the days of
Jim Crow segregation and dominance," or whose chairman,
Julian Bond, said, "(President Bush) has appeased the
wretched appetites of the extreme right wing and has
chosen Cabinet officials whose devotion to the
Confederacy is nearly canine in its uncritical
affection"?
It's always been my contention that the conservative
vision shows far greater respect for blacks than the
liberal you-can't-make-it-without-us vision. For
decades, there have been buy-off-the-black-vote
presidential appointments like secretaries of labor,
health and human services, education and housing. But
it's been conservative presidents who have appointed
blacks to top positions of responsibility and authority
such as secretary of state, national security adviser,
chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Republican
presidents didn't make these appointments to buy off the
black vote. They chose the best people around, who just
happened to be black Americans.
Maybe it's guilt that motivates white liberals.
That's why I've graciously offered a Certificate of
Amnesty and Pardon (http://www.gmu.edu/departments/economics/wew/gift.html). |